Skip to content

Research · updated 2026-11-18

Where MLB players use ABS challenges, and where they win them

2026 was the first MLB season with automated ball-strike challenges. MLB publishes the totals. I wanted the part the totals hide: where in the count players use a challenge, and whether they win it there. This covers 7,991 challenges from 1,931 games, May 6 to October 28, 2026, counted from 293,373 called pitches.

Three things the data says

  • Players challenge most when the count matters most. 2.1% of called pitches at 0-0 were challenged, 4.0% at 2-2 and 6.2% on a full count.
  • That is exactly where they lose. 60.0% of challenges at 0-0 were overturned, against 47.6% at 2-2. With two strikes the win rate was 50.2%; with fewer, 57.7%. The challenges players care most about are the ones they lose most. Triple-A showed the same thing in 2025.
  • Challenges did not cause this year's walk bump. Walks were up to 8.4% of plate appearances. Overturns removed 71 more walks than they created and added 72 more strikeouts than they took away: about 0.05 points each. Something else moved walks.

Challenges by count

CountCalled pitchesChallengesChallenge rateOverturnedWin rate
0-098,1012,0582.1%1,23560.0%
0-136,7988842.4%54561.7%
0-218,8123812.0%20754.3%
1-031,3177772.5%47360.9%
1-125,3298543.4%46154.0%
1-223,3385872.5%29750.6%
2-011,1493453.1%19857.4%
2-112,2965534.5%27449.5%
2-216,4546584.0%31347.6%
3-05,450911.7%5156.0%
3-15,9602844.8%13748.2%
3-28,3695196.2%25949.9%
Count before the pitch. Called pitches are balls and called strikes after review. Win rate is the share of challenges that overturned the call.

By the call on the field

Original callChallengesOverturnedWin rate
Ball4,4642,55657.3%
Strike3,5271,89453.7%
A ball challenged and turned into a strike, or a strike turned into a ball. Overall, 55.7% of challenges won.

Calls that ended a plate appearance

At two strikes or three balls an overturn decides whether the plate appearance ends on that pitch. That happened 1,264 times.

EffectCreatedRemovedNet
Strikeouts574502+72
Walks188259-71
Created: a ball turned into strike three, or a strike turned into ball four. Removed: the reverse.

Strikeouts and walks, same window each year

SeasonGamesPlate appearancesK%BB%
20221,931145,18422.267.80
20231,886142,96422.668.27
20241,880141,13122.577.76
20251,892142,54222.267.95
20261,891142,93122.148.42
Regular season, May 6 to Sep 27. 2026 strikeouts sit inside the 22.3 to 22.7% range of 2022-25; walks are above the 7.8 to 8.3% range. This is a comparison, not a cause.

How it was counted

Every 2026 regular-season and postseason game from May 6. Challenge outcomes are labeled in our pitch data only from that date, so this covers about 78% of the season; earlier games are left out rather than counted as zero challenges.

For each challenged pitch: the count before the pitch, the original call (worked out from the final call and whether it was overturned) and the result. There is no per-challenge record of who challenged (batter, catcher or pitcher) or how many challenges a team had left, so this says nothing about challenger roles.

Context: MLB's review of the 2025 Triple-A season found batters won 45% of challenges overall but 36% with two strikes and 34% on full counts (Mike Petriello, MLB.com, February 26, 2026). The pitch-by-pitch rows behind this page come from get_pitches and get_plate_appearances; see the MLB pitch-by-pitch data API.

Use these numbers

Cite this page, or download every table above as one CSV.

Download CSV